There may have been no forbidden romance, but there's no denying the huge impact that Anning left on Murchison, or the fact that she chose to live her life surrounded by brilliant, pioneering women. “She not only introduced him into the world of minerals, rocks and fossils, but took an active part in the scientific pursuits which she had initiated, which leads us to conclude that her views are intimately connected with Roderick Murchison’s work.” “Who is aware that there would have never been a geologist Roderick Murchison without the encouragement from a woman?” Martina Kölbl-Ebert writes in a 1997 'Earth Sciences History' article, according to Time. It was Murchison's husband that won all the plaudits (he was the president of the Geological Society for many years), but many believed that Charlotte played a pivotal role in their success. Meanwhile, the enthusiasm that Anning inspired in Charlotte Murchison is reflected in the latter's legacy. It's also true that she shared a friendship with her neighbour and fellow fossil collector Elizabeth Philpot, played by Fiona Shaw in the film. “The extraordinary thing in this young woman is that she has made herself so thoroughly acquainted with the science that the moment she finds any bones she knows to what tribe they belong,” she wrote. According to Time, The Geological Society has records of a glowing diary entry written by a tourist, Lady Harriet Silvester, who visited Anning in 1824. (Anning inherited her life’s passion from her cabinetmaker father, Richard, who collected and sold fossils to help pay off his family’s debts.) The ichthyosaur (“fish lizard”) that she excavated as a child was displayed at the National History Museum, and she did spend much of her time finding and selling fossils to tourists, who would often travel to meet her specifically (she is often claimed to be the inspiration for tongue-twister "She sells seashells on the seashore"). Anning was one of 10 children, only two of whom survived to adulthood. It’s really made me ask, ‘What can I make next? What am I allowed to have a voice in?’Īll that being said, the film is faithful when it comes to other details. “What does it mean? Does it mean a woman can’t make a film about a man? Does it mean a person of colour can’t make a film about white people, or a non-queer person can’t make a film about queer people or vice versa? That all starts to feel difficult for me, because I don’t know what we’re going to be left with. “I think it makes things very complicated now,” he told us in the same interview. He was even erroneously referred to as a straight man. Many on social media took aim at the fact that a man (albeit a working class member of the LGBTQ+ community) was taking on a lesbian love story, accusing him of working from white male privilege. That wasn’t the only criticism he received, however. So, it just felt like couldn’t be with a man. Why would I be giving her a man to have a relationship with, when the patriarchy at that time had sidelined her and taken away her voice? I wanted her to be with someone who she could be equal to. “My reason for suggesting that Mary Anning had a relationship with a woman felt like it was coming from a place of integrity It felt like a way to elevate her and give her the respect she should have had at the time. He revisited the topic in a recent interview with Esquire (that’s us), saying: “To me, Mary felt like a figure from history who had been ignored, who had no voice and had been passed over And that was because she was working class and a woman. She lived with her mother, never wed and died childless, while Murchison continued to travel and work with her husband on geological pursuits. But the lesbian love affair that forms between the two women in the film is (by all historical accounts) a fiction, inspired by the mystery around Anning's romantic life. It’s also true that Charlotte Murchison, played by Saoirse Ronan, visited and worked with her in Lyme Regis on Dorset’s Jurassic Coast, alongside her geologist husband Roderick Murchison (James McArdle). Mary Anning, played by Kate Winslet, was indeed a pioneering palaeontologist from the 1800s who was disrespected and taken advantage of by the patriarchal establishment of her time. The answer to the first question is yes and no, but mostly no. So is Ammonite a true story? And more importantly, does it really matter? It’s been a long wait, and not one free of controversy from the moment it was announced in 2019, many social media critics and historians took issue with the film's 'authenticity', for wholly different reasons. Warning: this article is one big spoiler for Ammoniteįive months after it was released in the US, Francis Lee’s Ammonitehas finally landed upon our rocky shore.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |